Niobium oxynitride (NbOxNy) thin films with varying combined non-metal vs. metal stoichiometries ( x + y ) and N/O stoichiometric ratios (y/x) are investigated for their ability to catalyze the nitrogen re-duction reaction and ammonia synthesis at ambient conditions. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and ammonia measurements show stark differences both in nitrogen vs. argon media on each surface and on the surfaces in the series when the combined stoichiometry of N + O vs. Nb increases. Surface stability checks at fixed intervals during the experiments and surface characterization after the experiments us -ing X-ray diffraction reveal the least changes occurred to the surface with the highest N + O stoichiometry. Based on these observations, an ammonia synthesis mechanism is proposed. Isotope labeling experiments on the most promising surface of the series, however, show no sign of catalytically produced ammonia, possibly due to the lack of stability of the surface to endure through the ammonia production cycle.