Genetic incompatibilities causing intrinsic post-zygotic isolation in terms of hybrid sterility and/or inviability ensure the long-term stability of reproductive isolation between diverging lineages. Despite a well-established theoretical foundation and empirical evidence from laboratory experiments, how genetic incompatibilities build up in nature remains poorly understood. Different ecological environments can invoke divergent natural selection on mitochondrial aerobic metabolism, a critical physiological trait controlled by co-evolving mitochondrial and nuclear genomes, and thereby cause mitonuclear incompatibilities between lineages. In this thesis, I investigate the arise of intrinsic postzygotic isolation from divergent ecological adaptation in naturally hybridising pied (Ficedula hypoleuca) and collared flycatchers (Ficedula albicollis), with mitochondrial aerobic metabolism as the crucial phenotypic link. Using long-term monitoring data, I first find viability reductions in hybrids throughout their lifespan, strong at the embryonic stage and subtler later in life, and different mortality trajectories between hybrid adults from reciprocal crosses (Paper I). The results indicate emerging genetic incompatibilities involving segregating or mild-effect alleles and possible mitonuclear incompatibilities. I then reveal ecologically based divergence of mitochondrial aerobic metabolism in Ficedula flycatchers and a complicated, multi-level molecular basis to the divergence (Paper II). Collared flycatchers have more efficient energy production due to high Complex I function in the oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) pathway. This difference likely contributes to subtle differences in environmental sensitivity, competitive ability, incubation temperature and nestling growth potential between the two species. My results imply that natural selection has favoured new adaptive mutations in the mitochondrial genome as well as complementary changes based on standing variation in the nuclear genome. Next, I find that hybrid adults generally resemble the parental species in mitochondrial aerobic respiration (Paper III). Individuals carrying severe BDMIs may have died during earlier energy-demanding life stages such as growth and migration. However, I find evidence for transgressive gene expression in one of the body’s most metabolically demanding tissues, the liver. Finally, I discover that hybrid nestlings have more costly and less efficient metabolism accompanied by high mortality, slower growth and lower fledging mass (a fitness proxy) as compared to non-hybrid nestlings sharing the same rearing environment (Paper IV). I conclude that species divergence in Complex I may have impaired the coordination in the OXPHOS pathway but I have also revealed other candidate BDMI loci. This is the first study exploring the phenotypic consequences of mitonuclear incompatibilities in avian hybrids during the energetically costly nestling stage. Overall, my work demonstrates that divergent natural selection on mitochondrial aerobic metabolism can promote intrinsic postzygotic isolation, leading to ecological speciation.
Evolutionary adaptation occurs when individuals vary in access to fitness-relevant resources and these differences in ‘material wealth’ are heritable. It is typically assumed that the inheritance of material wealth reflects heritable variation in the phenotypic abilities needed to acquire material wealth. We scrutinise this assumption by investigating additional mechanisms underlying the inheritance of material wealth in collared flycatchers. A genome-wide association analysis reveals a high genomic heritability (h2 = 0.405 ± 0.08) of access to caterpillar larvae, a fitness-relevant resource, in the birds' breeding territories. However, we find little evidence for heritable variation in phenotypic abilities needed to acquire this material wealth. Instead, combined evidence from simulations, experimental and long-term monitoring data indicate that inheritance of material wealth is largely explained by philopatry causing a within-population genetic structure across a heterogeneous landscape. Therefore, allelic variants associated with high material wealth may spread in the population without having causal connections to traits promoting local adaptation.
Hybrid inviability is an important post-zygotic reproductive barrier between species, but emerging signs of reduced viability can be difficult to study across the lifespan of natural hybrids. We use a combination of long-term monitoring, extra-pair paternity, and mitochondrial DNA identification in a natural hybrid zone of Ficedula flycatchers to detect emerging signs of intrinsic hybrid inviability across their entire lifespan. We evaluate possible evidence of Darwin's corollary to Haldane's rule, predicting asymmetries in inviability between hybrids resulting from reciprocal crosses, due to incompatible genetic factors with sex-specific inheritance patterns. We found higher hatching failure among mixed-species pairs, possibly indicating early developmental impairments associated with specific parental genetic combinations. Adult hybrids had a higher basal mortality rate than both parental species and different age-specific mortality trajectories. There were signs of differences in age-independent mortality rates between the reciprocal hybrid crosses: hybrids with a pied flycatcher mother experienced slightly increased mortality later in life. Using an exceptional dataset with many natural hybrids tracked across life stages, we provide evidence for several emerging signs of reduced hybrid viability. Incompatibilities between alleles located on autosomes and uniparentally inherited factors such as Z-linked and/or mitochondrial genes are strong candidates underlying intrinsic hybrid dysfunction in this system.
Seasonal environmental fluctuations provide formidable challenges for living organisms, especially small ectotherms such as butterflies. A common strategy to cope with harsh environments is to enter diapause, but some species avoid unsuitable conditions by migrating. Despite a growing understanding of migration in the life cycles of some butterfly species, it remains unknown how individuals register and store environmental cues to determine whether and where to migrate. Here, we explored how competition and host plant availability during larval development affect patterns of DNA methylation in the migratory painted lady (Vanessa cardui) butterfly. We identify a set of potentially functional methylome shifts associated with differences in the environment, indicating that DNA methylation is involved in the response to different conditions during larval development. By analysing the transcriptome for the same samples used for methylation profiling, we also uncovered a non-monotonic relationship between gene body methylation and gene expression. Our results provide a starting point for understanding the interplay between DNA methylation and gene expression in butterflies in general and how differences in environmental conditions during development can trigger unique epigenetic marks that might be important for behavioural decisions in the adult stage.
Phenotypic plasticity is commonly observed in nature, though little is known about the genetic architecture underlying this phenomenon. Using artificial selection lines of the seed beetle Callosobruchus maculatus, I aimed to investigate evolution of body size plasticity in the context of interplay between sex-specific selection and thermal stress, and the epigenetic inheritance of the parental phenotypic response. Contrary to my initial expectation, sexually antagonistic selection did not preserve more plasticity relative to directional selection. Rather, absolute plasticity positively changed with increasing body size after selection. Relative plasticity (per body weight) changed less and in opposite direction. This suggests high correlation of plastic body size variation with mean body size, and a partially independent genetic architecture of the relativized aspect of plasticity. Still, plasticity is sex specific and environmentally sensitive, generating possibility of some variation in sexual size dimorphism across environments. Developmental mechanism behind different temperature responses lies in diverging growth rate and developmental time. Cross- and trans-generational effects were observed, confirming that plastic response to environmental conditions can be epigenetically inherited and can potentially evolve. My results highlighted the importance of understanding the relationship between selection, phenotype, and plasticity, and showed that environmental stress could have prolonged effect through epigenetic inheritance.
ORCID: 0000-0001-7861-7359
Hybrid inviability is an important post-zygotic reproductive barrier between species but emerging signs of intrinsic dysfunction can be difficult to study across the lifespan of natural hybrids. Here, we use a combination of long-term monitoring of individuals in a natural hybrid zone of Ficedula flycatchers together with information on extra-pair paternity and mitochondrial DNA identification with the main goal of detecting emerging signs of intrinsic hybrid inviability across the entire lifespan of these naturally hybridizing birds. We also evaluate possible evidence of Darwin’s corollary to Haldane’s rule, which predicts asymmetries in the degree of inviability between hybrids resulting from reciprocal crosses, due to incompatible genetic factors with sex-specific inheritance patterns. We found higher hatching failure among mixed-species pairs, which could indicate early developmental impairments associated with specific parental genetic combinations. Adult hybrids had a higher basal mortality rate than both parental species, and different age-specific mortality trajectories. There were some signs of differences in age-independent mortality rates between the reciprocal hybrid crosses, with hybrid individuals with a pied flycatcher mother experiencing slightly increased mortality rates later in life. Clashes between the maternally inherited mitochondrial genome and part of the paternally inherited nuclear genome in these hybrids, leading to reduced efficiency of the cellular energy metabolism, are good candidates underlying intrinsic postzygotic isolation in this system.