Dissolved organic matter (DOM) is a vast and complex chemical mixture that plays a key role in the mediation of the global carbon cycle. Fundamental understanding of the source and fate of oceanic organic matter is obscured due to poor definition of the key molecular contributors to DOM, which limits accurate sample analysis and prediction of the Earth's carbon cycle. Previous work has attempted to define the components of the DOM through a variety of chromatographic and spectral techniques. However, modern preparative and analytical methods have not isolated or unambiguously identified molecules from DOM. Therefore, previously proposed structures are based solely on the mixture's aggregate properties and do not accurately describe any true individual molecular component. In addition to this, there is a lack of appropriate analogues of the individual chemical classes within DOM, limiting the scope of experiments that probe the physical, chemical, and biological contributions from each class. To address these problems, we synthesized a series of analogues of carboxylate-rich alicyclic molecules (CRAM), a molecular class hypothesized to exist as a major contributor to DOM. Key analytical features of the synthetic CRAMs were consistent with marine DOM, supporting their suitability as chemical substitutes for CRAM. This new approach provides access to a molecular toolkit that will enable previously inaccessible experiments to test many unproven hypotheses surrounding the ever-enigmatic DOM.