We define what it means for a Laurent polynomial in two variables to be mutable. For a mutable Laurent polynomial we prove several results about f and its period pi(f) in terms of the Newton polygon of f. In particular, we give an in principle complete description of the monodromy of pi(f) around the origin. Special attention is given to the class of maximally mutable Laurent polynomials, which has applications to the conjectured classification of Fano manifolds via mirror symmetry.