Dual Consciousness: What Psychology and Counseling Theories Can Teach and Learn Regarding Identity and the Role-Playing Game Experience
2023 (English)In: Journal of Roleplaying Studies and STEAM, E-ISSN 2992-7803, Vol. 2, no 2, p. 5-37, article id 4Article in journal (Refereed) Published
Abstract [en]
Many psychologists, therapists, and educators have emphasized the practice of play, especially with enacted roles, as a site for learning and therapeutic growth. This article weaves together a plethora of theories from psychology, Counseling, and role-playing game studies in an effort to understand the nature of enacted roles, their relationship to identity, and their transformative potential. Challenging the notion that identity is a fixed, stable monolith, the article synthesizes four overall approaches to theorizing the nature of identity drawn from various theories: identity as a social construct, narrative identity, identity as psychodynamic, and identities as parts of a whole. The authors posit that these ways of framing identity can help role-players, designers, and facilitators better understand the multifaceted nature of selfhood. This work holds implications for understanding the enactment of characters in role-playing games, especially with regard to the transformative potential of the role-playing experience.
Throughout the article, we also explore the psychology of play from the perspective of therapeutic practices and modalities that exist outside of the discourses of role-playing games as a hobby or field of academic study. We will emphasize how role-play, identity shifting, narrative, and embodied enactment are present in many existing therapeutic processes to various degrees. Examples include psychosynthesis, Gestalt therapy, drama therapy, narrative therapy, Internal Family Systems, and person-centred therapy. We will highlight clinical therapists who use role-playing games to augment more traditional practices.
Furthermore, while role-taking activities are central to many human experiences throughout time, the article will emphasize benefits the imagination space of role-playing games, particularly with regard to prolonged perspective taking, co-creative improvisation, the alibi of fiction, and increased agency and empowerment. The article will also address limitations to the form that might interrupt its transformative potential, such as cognitive dissonance, identity defense, and difficulties with integrating these experiences within one’s life narrative after they conclude.
Abstract [es]
Muchos psicólogos, terapeutas y educadores han enfatizado la práctica del juego, especialmentecon la interpretación de roles, como parte del aprendizaje y el crecimiento terapéutico. Este artículoentreteje una plétora de teorías de la psicología, la consejería y los estudios de juegos de rolen un esfuerzo por comprender la naturaleza de la interpretación de roles, su relación con la identidady su potencial transformador. Desafiando la noción de que la identidad es un monolito fijo yestable, este artículo sintetiza cuatro enfoques generales para teorizar la naturaleza de la identidadextraídos de diversas teorías: la identidad como una construcción social, la identidad narrativa,la identidad como psicodinámica y las identidades como partes de un todo. Los autores postulanque estas formas de enmarcar la identidad pueden ayudar a los actores de rol, diseñadores y facilitadoresa comprender mejor la naturaleza multifacética de la individualidad. Este trabajo tieneimplicaciones para la comprensión de la representación de los personajes en los juegos de rol,especialmente en lo que respecta al potencial transformador de la experiencia del juego de rol.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
Rangel Jiménez Mauricio , 2023. Vol. 2, no 2, p. 5-37, article id 4
Keywords [en]
role-playing games, RPG, psychology, counseling, counselling, role-playing game studies, larp, tabletop, identity, transformative, transformation
Keywords [es]
identidad, psicología, consejería, teoría, juegos de rol
National Category
Psychology Design
Research subject
Psychology
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-516609OAI: oai:DiVA.org:uu-516609DiVA, id: diva2:1814580
2023-11-252023-11-252025-03-14Bibliographically approved